← All Episodes
Behind the Ticker

Haren Bhakta, Inside Ownership

Why the S&P Will Buy More Berkshire When Buffett Dies

·28 min
S&P 500 free-float adjustmentWeighting by insider dollar ownershipOwner-operators versus hired CEOsOwner-run companies in a crisisWhere an owner-weighted index fits

Haren Bhakta has been going to the Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting since 2017. In 2024 he sat in that room for the first meeting without Charlie Munger, holding a lot of Berkshire stock and a question he couldn't shake. What happens to his shares when Warren Buffett is gone? He doesn't believe in the company the same way without him. Halfway through the meeting it hit him. The S&P 500 will buy more Berkshire on the day Buffett dies.

That one observation became an index. Haren started out selling insurance in 2008 because nobody else was hiring, moved to wealth management at Merrill Lynch and then Morgan Stanley, and broke away in 2017 to run his own firm and a micro cap fund. He won a proxy fight, got a board seat, and sold that company in 2023. Today he's founder and CEO of the Inside Ownership Index.

The Shares the S&P Leaves Out

The S&P 500 is weighted by free-float adjusted market cap. Shares held by founders and controlling insiders don't count. Haren put it in round numbers. Call Berkshire a trillion-dollar company. Buffett owns about 20% of it, so the index counts roughly $800 billion. When he dies, that stake starts to trade, and the index adds it back.

His point is that this is backwards. Who wants more Berkshire without Buffett, more Tesla without Elon Musk, or more Meta without Mark Zuckerberg? You want the exposure while the owner is there and less of it once they're gone.

He gave a cleaner example. In July 2020 Intel and Nvidia were both about $250 billion companies, each close to 1% of the S&P. Intel had seven times the revenue, seven times the profit, a higher return on equity and a higher free cash flow yield. Nvidia had a founder CEO with a big stake who went to bed thinking about the company and woke up thinking about it. The S&P gave the two companies the same weight anyway. That's the example I keep coming back to.

21,000 Proxy Filings

He came home from Omaha and went looking for the data. Bloomberg, Capital IQ and FactSet didn't have insider ownership going back far enough. So he read the proxy filings himself, about 21,000 of them covering roughly 20 years. He also went back a hundred years for context. General Motors under Alfred Sloan. IBM under Thomas Watson Jr., two and a half times the size of the next biggest company in the world in 1984, out of the top ten eight years after Watson retired. GE under Jack Welch. Over and over, a dominant company faded after the owner-operator left. Apple is the one clear exception he found.

The method is simple. Start with the S&P 500. Take the 100 companies with the largest dollar value of insider ownership. Weight each one by that dollar value instead of by total market cap. He uses dollars rather than a percentage stake on purpose, so the index stays close to market cap. He calls it market cap seen through skin in the game. Apple still makes it, because Tim Cook and the board chair each own about a billion dollars of stock. It's just underweight.

A board seat with real ownership is enough to qualify. Buffett didn't found Berkshire and Howard Schultz didn't found Starbucks. Both bought in and became the owner later.

Zoo Lions and Wild Lions

Haren calls a hired CEO a zoo lion. It gets fed every day whether the hunt works or not, with a base salary, a bonus and often a golden parachute. The owner-operator is a wild lion. When the hunt fails, it starves. In a crisis, that shows up two ways. Owners can get to capital when nobody else can, and they can make a call without a committee. If Zuckerberg wants to pay an AI researcher $200 million, he signs it.

It's more concentrated, so he finds the index more volatile than the S&P in an ordinary market. He'd still use it in place of the S&P as the core holding.

Talk it through

THOR builds adaptive index strategies for advisers and allocators. Fifteen minutes with our founder and CIO gets you the mechanism, the index history, and an honest read on where it fits. Book a time.

Full Transcript

4,402 words

Machine transcribed from Brad Roth's conversation with Haren Bhakta, Inside Ownership. Timestamps link to that moment on YouTube. Lightly cleaned, otherwise unedited.

0:00

Welcome to Behind the Ticker, the podcast where we go beyond the symbol and into the strategy. I'm Brad Roth, founder and chief investment officer at Thor Funds. And in each episode, I sit down with ETF managers, CIOs, and industry leaders to break down how these funds are actually built, how they behave in real markets, and how advisors use them in real portfolios. Most people just see a ticker symbol, but we know much more goes on behind the ticker. Hey Aaron, welcome to the show. Hey, thanks for having me.

0:43

So why don't you start off by giving everybody a bit about your background. I think I read you started at Merrill Lynch at Prudential, spent a handful of years over at Morgan Stanley, and then you started your own advisory firm. And today you're the founder and CEO of the Inside Ownership Index. Can you kind of walk us through how that whole path unfolded? Yeah, well, I think my grandmother gave me a little bit of money early on, like when I was 18, and I just fell in love with the stock market. Eventually, I wanted to get in the industry, and it was 2008. And the only way I can get in was to sell insurance. Nobody was hiring. So I joined Prudential. Eventually, in 2010, the firms were hiring again. So I joined Merrill Lynch,

1:26

Doing wealth management. In 2012, I joined Morgan Stanley, spent five and a half years there, managing money for high net worth individuals. In 2017, I broke away and started my own. And really, the reason why I left Morgan Stanley was I wanted to do things that you can do at the wire houses. So I created a micro cap fund investing in thinly traded, very small publicly traded companies, did a proxy contest and won, got on the board, and eventually sold that company in 2023. And in 2024 is when I thought of the idea of the Inside Ownership Index, while sitting at the Berkshire annual meeting, because I'm a huge Warren Buck fan. And now I'm just focused on that. We have the ETF and, trying to build brand awareness and get the word out there.

2:23

And that's what I wanted to ask you. you stole one of the questions from me. This idea came out of the 2024 Berkshire Hathaway annual meeting. what were you thinking in that room? And like, how eventually did you turn this into an index? Yeah, well, I was sitting there in 2020. I've been attending since 2017. And in 2024, it was the first meeting Charlie Munger wasn't there because he had passed away. So I just kind of had in the back of my mind, kind of this fear, like, I have a lot of Berkshire stock, what am I going to do with my stock when Warren Buffett passes away? Because I don't believe in the company the same way without him. And halfway through the meeting, it actually hit me that the S&P will actually be buying more Berkshire,

Read the full transcript (30 more sections)
3:05

Essentially on the death of Warren Buffett. I just thought, well, a lot of people don't make that connection. The S&P is what's called free float adjusted market cap. So Berkshire might be a trillion dollars, but they're only counting 800 billion that the 200 billion that he owns or 20% that he owns is not counted. But when he dies, those shares will become free floating. And I just thought, well, why would anybody want more exposure to Berkshire absent Warren Buffett? And in the same respect, who would want more exposure to Tesla without Elon Musk or Meta without Mark Zuckerberg, right? These guys are super geniuses. We should want more exposure to these companies while they're there and their ownership is there and less so when they're gone. And so I came home from Omaha and just

3:56

Like had to find all this ownership data. And I looked at Bloomberg, CapIQ, FactSet, all the data providers. And surprisingly, nobody actually had the ownership data going back that far. So I had to manually go through every proxy filing and collect the data myself. And I went back 20 years to launch the index. But I went back 100 years to kind of see, well, what would it look like had you invested? And, for 100 years, you could see that the best performing companies had leadership at the top that was responsible. And once those leaders were gone, the companies typically went through a decay. And I went back 100 years, looked at the number one company in the world. And like 1930 to 1950 was General Motors. And it was one man,

4:55

Alfred Sloan, responsible. IBM was the biggest company in the world in the 70s and 80s. And again, there's one guy responsible for that. It was Thomas Watson Jr., the son of the founder. He was the chairman of the board. And for most of that time, and, Jack Welch with GE. The only exception I could really find is like Apple, Apple has continued to do well despite despite Steve Jobs not being around. So there's exceptions. But for the most part, the index has a basket of stocks run by owners. Interesting. Well, we're going to get into the we're going to get into the fun and the strategy here in a minute. Before we do that, though, I always like to ask every guest, what do you what

5:40

Do you like to do when you're not working? Any hobbies? I play a little bit of beach volleyball. Yeah, for exercise. And I read a lot. I go out to dinner, enjoy nice dinners. Love that. So let's get into own, which is the ETF behind the or I should say in front of this index, the index is behind it, which is the inside ownership 100 ETF. This was launched on June 3rd at a high level. We kind of touched on it, but really at a high level, what is this fund and what is the core problem that it's solving? Yeah, well, the I like to tell people there's like three ways you could index. OK, the first is equal weighted. You could buy S&P 500 equal weighted and you systematically buy every

6:25

Single company equally. And, every quarter you trim the ones that go up and you feed the ones that go down. It's systematic buy low, sell high. Right. Or you recognize that there's going to be some extreme winners and they're going to compound earnings for a very long time. And you want to increase your exposure as those companies grow. So you market cap weight or you recognize that there's going to be a handful of individuals that really change the world, but you don't know which ones. So rather than index the market cap, you index to the individuals behind the corporation, the owners. And, again, you don't know which ones are going to really take off, but but you index to them. And what you get is a handful of exceptional leaders that really hit the

7:22

Ball in the park, like Jensen, Elon Musk, Warren Buffett, Mark Zuckerberg, Jeff Bezos. So by indexing to these leaders, you really get it's more power law driven. So you're getting more exposure to these extraordinary companies, extraordinary, extraordinary leaders. So the core argument that you made earlier, and I just want to touch on it again, because for the advisors listening to the show, I think it's important. The core argument is how the S&P is actually built because it's free float adjusted, which means shares held by founders and controlling insiders get excluded. So like walk us through why that matters in practice. Well, think about it. The best investors in the world are actually not investors at all. They're entrepreneurs who never sold. So why would you want to exclude shares that are held by the best

8:12

Investors or the best value creators in the world? Right? It makes no sense. You should want to have more exposure to these companies while these leaders are there. So think you have two companies, A and B. A, and let's call them identical. Identical companies doing identical things and identical size. But company B has a CEO who owns 20% of the company. And company A is run by a boardroom, with a CEO, hired CEO, and a boardroom with really, owns no stock. The S&P will give you more exposure to company A, when probably company B is the one that you want to maximize exposure to. And, the actual example I have for that is Intel and NVIDIA. So in July of 2020,

9:10

Intel and NVIDIA were identical companies. They're both $250 billion companies, almost the same weighting in the S&P around 1%. Intel had seven times the revenue of NVIDIA at that moment, seven times the profits, a higher return on equity and a higher free cash flow yield. But NVIDIA had something Intel didn't, right? It had a CEO, a founder CEO with extreme ownership, who went to bed thinking about the company, woke up thinking about it. And, fast forward six years, NVIDIA has created enormous wealth for shareholders, more than 2000%. And Intel has underperformed the market, right? So I think investors have paid too little attention to, to how much the CEO and the board own, and what they're capable of, and probably too much attention

10:07

To last year's earnings. And more and more, I think studying the last year's earnings is going to be less predictive of what future earnings are going to look like, especially with AI. The world is changing too fast and using last year's earnings or earnings five years ago is not going to tell you much about what earnings are going to look like five years from now. So walk us through the methodology a little bit. You start with the S&P 500 as the entire universe, and then pick the top 100 by dollar value of insider ownership, right? And then you wait by insider stake instead of market cap. So why dollar value rather than percentage?

10:52

Well, we want to be somewhat like market cap. So essentially, we're counting the market cap of each company by only the shares held by insiders rather than all the shares outstanding. We're just taking a subset of the shares outstanding and using that to proportionately weight the portfolio. And what my argument is, is that that layer of shares has more informational value than all the shares outstanding. Right? So who owns those shares and how much, their worth is very important.

11:35

The fact that Larry Page and Sergey or Jeff Bezos or Mark Zuckerberg own this very high dollar amount of shares. And they didn't start out that way. They grew to that value, right? So you're in that you're, you're, you're simply indexing to that dollar value as it grows. And then when they're gone, um, you're not going to have exposure to these companies or, or much less. For example, Apple is still in the IO 100 because the dollar value of ownership by, by Tim Cook and, and, uh, the chairman of the board, um, Art Levinson, they say they own about a billion dollars each.

12:18

So still a significant value. So Apple still makes it just, it just underweighted position. So by using the dollar weight, you're not straying too far away from, from market cap. So it's essentially kind of like looking at market cap through the lens of skin of the game. So all the data comes from, as you already mentioned, you went through all these proxy filings, about 21,000 proxy filings over 21 years of data. I'm just curious, like, have you thought about, or would you have any interest? Because it seems like pretty heavy work. Um, looking even farther down the line into summer, like small and midsize companies, rather than just the largest that are already in the S&P 500. Do you think there's additional value potentially there?

13:01

David Morgan There's additional value. Well, for one, um, uh, small and mid cap, the problem with that is now you're going to have a handful of individuals, um, really create significant value. And you don't know which ones those are going to be. The problem with small and mid cap is the best ones grow out of it. And large cap, you get maximum exposure all the way through time. So you imagine, investing in Nvidia in 2020. Um, and, uh, a year or two later, it grows out of being a mid cap. And now you have to go find another mid cap. So that's the problem. Um, a few companies really hit the ball in the park and you want to maintain that exposure to them and let them compound. And a problem with a small cap, um,

13:54

Index is that, it's the best ones are very quickly going to grow out of it. So it doesn't work as well. And I tried to go further back for the index. Um, but the problem was, it was very hard to get ownership data beyond 2004. Uh, a lot of the, half the companies in the, in the S&P actually don't even exist anymore back in the nineties because, they were either acquired, went bankrupt or, um, they're just not around. So I tried to go back further than 20 years, but again, like none of the data providers have any ownership. Even the proxy filings are very hard to find beyond 20 years ago. Interesting. So when I was looking at the top portfolio holdings,

14:39

It looks like NVIDIA, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, Tesla, Berkshire, an advisor might look at that and say, this looks a lot like the S&P where does own actually diverge, start to diverge from the S&P? Well, the, the position sizing, so, the index is still the same companies. So for example, equal S&P 500 equal weighted and market cap weighted, it's still the same 500 companies, right? Um, but it's all in the weighting. So even though Google and NVIDIA and Amazon, they're, they're, they're the biggest position, they're extremely overweighted. So Google, for example, is that, uh, and NVIDIA are around 11 to 12% positions in the, in the index. And, um, Apple is still in there, but it's significantly underweighted. So it's all in the

15:27

Weighting really. So, um, if you look at the top 10, you'll see Dell, you'll see, uh, Palantir, you'll see Oracle. Uh, these are still founder led companies, um, with, uh, significant ownership. So we, we get more exposure. And if you look at the top 10 S&P, you're going to get like, um, uh, you like Lily, you're going to get, uh, I think that the last rebalance Exxon mobile was in the top 10 S&P, these are like no ownership type companies where, insiders are just hired CEOs. They really own no stock. Um, I went back a hundred years and looked at the top 10 companies through time at every decade. And what you see is, um,

16:18

Newer companies. If you look at a top 10 companies today in the world, uh, they were on average founded in the year 2000 is if you include open AI and at dropic, they were on average founded in the year 2000. And if you go to Europe and look at the top 10 companies in Europe, you'll find that they were on average founded about a hundred years ago. So this is the difference. Um, and Europe has had no growth over the last 20 years. Right. So this tells you that it really takes an entrepreneur with skin in the game to really create disruptive value and change the world. And, um, once those entrepreneurs are gone, uh, typically companies will go through a decay.

17:01

So your back test goes back to about 2005 and it shows roughly two percentage points of annual outperformance versus the S&P. And also it shows some smaller drawdowns in 20, uh, 2008, as well as 2020. Why do you believe just, um, with all the analysis you've done on these companies, why do owner operated companies not only tend to outperform when things are good, but also hold up better in crisis? Yeah. Well, think about it. Like, in 2008, um, there was a liquidity crunch and, companies didn't have access to capital, but it's these founders and these owner operators have that access to capital. And, secondly, they're able to pivot and make changes much quicker than a bureaucratic boardroom could, right? Mark Zuckerberg, if he wants to

17:54

Hire an AI scientist and offer $200 million, he could do that with, with a stroke of a pen, he doesn't have to go to a committee and get a vote, right? So these, these owner operators are, are able to make decisions quickly and make pivots and they have access to capital. So when the world is, um, really going wrong, like in 2008 or COVID pandemic, um, these owner operator companies are, are more resilient, right? Um, in a general volatility period, I find own, uh, or the inside ownership index to be more volatile because it's more concentrated. But when the world is really going wrong, something's happening. Um, at least in the last two major global catastrophic events, which was 2008, 2009 and 2020, um, S&P had deeper drawdowns.

18:54

Well, and it's just on your shirt, right? I was just making the other points as skin in the game, right? When it's your money and the stock is getting smoked, you're going to want to pivot or, or make decisions a lot faster. Um, and so I have a, I have a feeling that during result during time of crisis, the resiliency of a founder, not only because they've got skin in the game, but it's also their baby wants to pull them out of the mud quite a lot quicker than maybe somebody who's just collecting a paycheck and, and, eventually stock options. Exactly. So my favorite analogy is, um, I like to call a hired CEO, a, a zoo animal, a zoo lion, a zoo lion gets fed every day, whether it successfully hunts or not. Right. A, uh,

19:35

Very often the, the hire CEO has a base salary, um, quarterly bonus, and very often a golden parachute. Right. But the owner operator CEO, I like to call a wild lion. They're trained to survive. They've already proven that they can survive in the world. And when they don't successfully hunt, they feel the pain, they starve and they're able to make changes quicker and pivot. And, um, there's a guy named Matt Ridley. He wrote a book called how innovation works and how innovation really works is for one, you can't innovate through committee. Uh, and it's, it's feedback loops, short feedback loops, um, trial and error. And, uh, having the ability to make rapid changes and that's really how you create the separate value. I, I just read a book

20:25

About Jeff Bezos recently and, what's crazy is he tried to eliminate communication. Now, if you read a college textbook, they're going to talk about corporate communication, improving it. He's like, you know what? I don't, I don't want to improve communication. I want to eliminate it. And that's how you really create, um, innovation is, is by having these, these short feedback loops, having the people actually working on the problem directly, pivoting and making changes. And, uh, these large bureaucratic organizations, um, tend to, uh, have layers of management and communication up and down before things really happen. Um, if you look at Tesla, for example, they, they've made their patents for the electric car, um, open, open source. And yet these legacy car manufacturers are still haven't been able to

21:20

Really create the electric car. Right. Um, yet all his patents have been open source and it's, it's a structural problem. So there are other owner led funds, uh, in the space. Now, um, we've got FFF, which is, uh, Michael Moynihan's product. You got bang Creek's billionaire club, both of which I've had on the show. And, and what's great is the three of you all come to the same conclusion. Right. Which is you got skin in the game and you're a founder led company. That's something you need to pay attention to, but how is your index different than maybe how these funds are constructed other than, maybe just screening for founders or billionaires? Yeah. Well, what I found it's, it's, um, a little bit of the reverse order. So what I find is, um,

22:06

Sometimes you'll call a founder, a founder after the fact. So I'll give you an example. Warren Buffett is not technically the founder of Berkshire. He acquired Berkshire in 1965. Howard Schultz is not the founder of Starbucks, right? He acquired Starbucks from the 11 stores. So they become the founder later. Um, so it's really more about, um, owner operators and, the difference is, um, some of these other founder ETFs is they require the founder, uh, to be in a, um, uh, a leadership role in terms of, uh, either the chief executive, they have to be a C-suite for mine. They just have to be on the board. They need also, for example, Google, uh, Larry Page and Sergey brand. They're still in the office every day. Sergey brand is back in the office once AI became a big

22:56

Thing, but they're, they don't have a chief, uh, executive or chief technology officer type role, but they don't need it. Right. Um, they're, they're in the office working on it every day. So the difference is, um, I went back a hundred years. So for example, General Motors was the biggest company in the world in 1930 and it held that lead for more than 20 years. General Motors was the biggest company in the world by 1950, 20 years later, um, extremely dominant, but it, it didn't have a founder at the top. It had Alfred Sloan who was a CEO and it was the first company to have a decentralized, um, organization. It's the first time a large company became decentralized. So it, it helped all these like independent subsidiaries like Chrysler, old, um, Oldsmobile,

23:49

Uh, Buick. Um, so, uh, again, IBM in the eighties, 1984, IBM was two and a half times larger than the next largest company in the world. This is how dominant it was. It held that lead for also like two decades. Um, it was run by Thomas Watson jr, the son of the founder and he was the chairman of the board. He retires in 1984 from the, um, chairman role and completely retires. Um, eight years after his retirement, IBM was not in the top 10. So we're talking about the most dominant company to ever exist, even to this day, because at two and a half times larger than the next largest company, that would be like Nvidia today being $12 trillion, right? It was dominant and, and, um, no one could

24:40

Compete. And just eight years after his retirement, IBM falls out of the top 10. Uh, so, again, GE in, um, 2000 largest company in the world run by Jack Welch. He retires in 2001. General electric will probably never make it the top 10. Neither will, um, general motors or, or IBM. So the point is that, um, once these owner operators, now we can call them owners. Yeah. They're, they're not necessarily founders, but Jack Welch owned a, a lot of GE stock. Um, Thomas Watson jr. Obviously owned a lot of IBM. He was the son of the founder. Um, so, uh, it's really, um, kind of like the reverse order. It's, it's, it's these guys get labeled the founder, even if, uh, they're, they're just more owners and they hit the ball in the park and then, um, eventually they get labeled

25:40

The founder. So for an advisor, who's listening to this, they're thinking about buying or owning own, uh, how should they position the portfolio, right? Do you think it's a replacement for the S&P is a core holding? Should it sit alongside of it? Just like someone might hold equal weight and market cap weighted is just a, just a third idea that can sit up there with them. Yeah. Well, I, I would replace the S&P because, um, for one, what I like to tell advisors is, uh, because you're getting more of what's working, you could actually reduce equity exposure. And I think that's the most prudent thing you do right now is, is, is, um, in a 60, 40 portfolio, you might want to be 50, 50 right now, right. At these equity

26:27

Prices. Um, and what you could do is reduce exposure, but still get exposure to the, the companies that are working the best. Um, and, and hopefully you can keep up with the market. And, um, when we do get that correction, you could, you could add more exposure to the stock market, but, um, owned is a good way of maintaining your equity exposure, but having, um, less of it and still kind of keeping up with the market. Because again, you're having more of those, um, technology names, the ones that are kind of keeping up with the market are the ones that are really carrying the market. So Heron, I really appreciate you spending some time with me today before I can let you go there.

27:08

Where can people learn more about the index as well as the ETF? Yeah, well, we have a website inside ownership.com really easy inside ownership.com. You can get information on the ETF and the index methodology. I have a lot of videos on there as well, where people could, um, learn more about the methodology. Uh, and, uh, they could contact me on LinkedIn. I'm on LinkedIn quite a bit. All right. Well, Hey, I appreciate you spending some time with me today. Thanks for coming on. Yeah. Thanks for having me on.